« Getting to Know Garry Trudeau | Main | Appendicitis in Pooch Café - So Funny It Hurts! »

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c5f3053ef00d8342dc68753ef

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference For Better or For Worse - 2007...and Beyond?:

Comments

Kid Z

They still make this strip? Last storyline I remember was when Farley died, but then, I don't read the papers much anymore. Lyn Johnston's been putting this thing out for 30 years... not everyone's a Charles Schultz who can work and work until death... Lyn deserves some time off. At least she's going to still be doing some original material. As for the aging controversy, well it seems like it would just be too difficult to do anymore. Would you rather this strip end up like Gasoline Alley?

kozad

I have enjoyed this strip, especially as it ages the characters, unlike most strips. (Not that I would have endorsed Watterson's aging of Calvin!!!)

But the abrupt denigration of the quality of the artistry took me by surprise. I guess I missed something, looking back on these comments: the fact that we were somehow expected to be viewing these lives throught different spectacles now...

Altogether, a rather clumsy semi-ending to the kind of soap-opera strip that had sucked me in, despite my preference for hipper strips (Bizzaro, Zippy, Monty, Doonesbury, etc.).

jlt

Why bother any longer? The realistic aging and relatively realistic treatment of real world problems were the only things that kept this strip interesting, as it was never particularly funny (nor do I think it needed to be to be successful).

I think this is a bad choice and will make the strip completely irrelevant. If you can't keep it good, why do it at all? Nobody would fault you for leaving it at a good time; driving it into the ground only squanders the good will the strip's readers had for it.

christine

Lynn Johnston is very talented artistically and has an ear for dialogue. Her series FBorFW has been a joy throughout the years. Watching the character s grow and change, suffer setbacks, prosper, and now finally, come to their logical conclusion with Elizabeth's wedding in August 2008. Here is the problem with trying to re-run the whole thing from the get-go, it makes the characters seem irrelevant and ageless (agelessness is not that interesting). To freeze-frame them in time is NOT what made the original so special. They were nearly like living people who aged and grew as they did. Michael's family is the most boring and to focus on him in the repeats (at least starting out) is really not the way to go. I think Ms. Johnston should have just ended it with Elizabeth's wedding and the storyline that told what all the characters did in the coming years. To repeat it all now is pointless. It ruins the wonderful memory of it like they did with the "Peanuts" strip. I don't bother with that and haven't for years. Ageless characters (like the "Family Circus" group) are just boring and dreary. Anyway, Ms. Johnston and her characters had a great run of it. Will miss them. But so nice if she's have left well enough alone and we could merely imagine how they all would have ended up a couple of decades from now when Michael's children are grown and perhaps getting married; Elizabeth's too; and April eventually getting married but perhaps choosing NOT to have kids and concentrating on career. And finally, the aging and senior-hood of she and John (way their beyond retirement), and perhaps them becoming great-grandparents.

Lacoste shoes

It is easy to be wise after the event?You never know what you can do till you try?

coach suitcase

Just for today I will have a quiet half hour all by myself and relax. During this half hour, sometime, I will try to get a better perspective of my life.

gucci handbags

Do not easily say something about others. We should follow our own heart and interest, and fulfill what we should do instead of merely paying lip service and looking forward to the future. Did you agree with me? Posed By gucci handbags

Nike Shox For Sale

And for better or worse, the outcome of the global recession will be closer regulation of the world's economic and financial systems, for years to come.

Cheap Coach Handbags

You may believe these four proverbs:
All men are poets at heart.
Anger is a wind which blows out the lamp of the mind.
After the verb to love, to help is the most beautiful verb in the world.
Be not angry that you cannot make others as you wish them to be, since you cannot make yourself as you wish to be.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment


Tweets


Visit R.C. Harvey's Blog



About

Powered by TypePad